Cheddar Apple Pie Lighten Up! Replace the filling's granulated sugar with cup brown sugar and 2 tablespoons honey, and sub in low-fat Cheddar. 72 calories and 8 grams of fat per serving. Pin it to Save it! Classic Apple Pie Recipe, Best Apple Pie, Apple Pies, Easter Pie, Thanksgiving Pies, Apple Pie Recipes, Homemade Chocolate, Homemade Pies, Food Cravings